| Annual Scholar-Athletes |
| 2007 | Brandon, Hitchcock, Binghamton |
| 2006 |
Brendon Hitchcock, Binghamton |
| 2005 |
Aaron Izaryk, Maine |
| 2004 |
Aaron Izaryk, Maine |
| 2003 |
Brendan Ryan, Northeastern |
| 2002 |
Eddie Scott, Albany |
| 2001 |
Gregg Davies, Towson |
| 2000 |
Jason Sandner, Towson |
| 1999 |
Jason Rummel, Towson |
| 1998 |
Carlos Pena, Northeastern |
| 1997 |
Brian Biskupiak, Hartford |
| 1996 |
James Vallillo, Towson |
| 1995 |
Jeff Vallillo, Hofstra |
| 1994 |
Alex Pugliese, Delaware |
| 1993 |
Steve Matthews, Hartford |
| 1992 |
Steve Johnson, Vermont |