| 2003 All-Conference |
| First Team | Honorable Mention | All-Rookie |
| Ashlee Reed, Albany | Kelly McEathron, Hartford | Blair Buchanan, Albany |
| Eileen Nicole Rodriguez, Albany | Leah Guidinger, Maine | Ashley DeNeal, Albany |
| Anne Crocus, Binghamton | Brittany Howe, Maine | Ashley Meffert, Binghamton |
| Stephanie Volckers, Hartford | Erin Ludwig, New Hampshire | Brooke Truong, Maine |
| Jocelyn Teoh, UMBC | Sasha Scott, New Hampshire | Katie Weidner, New Hampshire |
| Alyson Coler, New Hampshire | Rebecca Holland, Northeastern | Whitney Turner, Northeastern |
| Erin Walker, New Hampshire |
| Larissa Adomat, Northeastern |
| Kristin Ursillo, Northeastern |
| Rachel Goldsmith, Stony Brook |
| Tesha Harry, Stony Brook |
| Julie Zub, Stony Brook |
|
| 2002 All-Conference |
| First Team | Honorable Mention | All-Rookie |
| Alissa Gibbs, Albany | Jill Dombrowksi, Albany | Alexis Bowens, Albany |
| Anne Crocus, Binghamton | Eileen Nicole Rodriguez, Albany | Eileen Nicole Rodriguez, Albany |
| Stephanie Volckers, Hartford | Kelly McEathron, Hartford | Leah Guidinger, Maine |
| Carmen Gabriel, Maine | Danielle Scoggin, Hartford | Amy Dai, New Hampshire |
| Alyson Coler, New Hampshire | Anne Davis, New Hampshire | Karen Harrington, New Hampshire |
| Lauren Knight, New Hampshire | Erin Ludwig, New Hampshire | Larisa Adomat, Northeastern |
| Larisa Adomat, Northeastern |
| Erin Spangler, Northeastern |
| Kristin Ursillo, Northeastern |
| Lindsay Wagner, Northeastern |
| LaToya Byerly, Stony Brook |
| Julie Zub, Stony Brook |
|
| 2001 All-Conference |
| First Team | Honorable Mention | All-Rookie |
| Leah Voss, Maine | Cheryl Elliott, Maine | Stephanie Volckers, Hartford |
| Stephanie Volckers, Hartford | Carmen Gabriel, Maine | Carmen Gabriel, Maine |
| Kristin Ursillo, Northeastern | Lauren Knight, New Hampshire | Bonnie Wilson, New Hampshire |
| Kristin Deatherage, Northeastern | Debra Falkenberg, Stony Brook | Liz Goubeaux, Towson |
| Erin Spangler, Northeastern | Melanie Madden, Towson | Sarah Miller, Towson |
| Gianini Pellegrini, Northeastern | Sarah Miller, Towson | Valerie Maloy, Stony Brook |
| Alissa Gibbs, Albany |
| Angela Tassone, Drexel |
| Alyson Coler, New Hampshire |
| Bonnie Wilson, New Hampshire |
| Andrea LeBlanc, Towson |
| Liz Goubeaux, Towson |
|
| 2000 All-Conference |
|
| First Team | Honorable Mention | All-Rookie |
| Stefanie Rewitz, Hofstra | Alyson Coler, New Hampshire | Alyson Coler, New Hampshire |
| Brie Katz, Hofstra | Cheryl Elliott, Maine | Cheryl Elliott, Maine |
| Kurtisa Shaw, Hofstra | Katie Jentes, New Hampshire | Allison Hunter, Delaware |
| Leah Voss, Maine | Andrea LeBlanc, Towson | April Nick, Hofstra |
| Jillian Ross, New Hampshire | Cameo Neeman, Delaware | Angela Tassone, Drexel |
| Stacy Barnett, New Hampshire | Suzana Stojakovic, Northeastern | Kristin Ursillo, Northeastern |
| Jennifer Walker, New Hampshire |
| Kristin Deatherage, Northeastern |
| Erin Spangler, Northeastern |
| Lindsay Wagner, Northeastern |
| Lindsey Rattet, Towson |
| Jennifer Wanner, Delaware |
|
| 1999 All-Conference |
|
| First Team | Second Team |
| Beth Cole, New Hampshire | Stacy Barnett, New Hampshire |
| Kristin Deatherage, Northeastern | Lindsey Birkel, Hofsrta |
| Enkelejda Katiraj, Hofstra | Leisha Campbell, New Hampshire |
| Gretchen Lavander, Hofstra | Joanna Dusza, Delaware |
| Lisa Nolan, Northeastern | Jillian Ross, New Hampshire |
| Jennifer Wanner, Delaware | Jennifer Walker, New Hampshire |
|
| 1998 All-Conference |
|
| First Team | Second Team |
| Stacy Barnett, New Hampshire | Kari Hall, Drexel |
| Leisha Campbell, New Hampshire | Laura Nissen, Hofstra |
| Carlyn Cangiano, Delaware | Lyssa Pershing, Towson |
| Enkelejda Katiraj, Hofstra | Jillian Ross, New Hampshire |
| Jessica Knott, Northeastern | Suzanne Shaw, Hofstra |
| Lisa Nolan | Jennifer Wanner, Delaware |
|
| 1997 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Lindsey Birkel Hofstra | Paige Harrison, Delaware |
| Bethany Cole, New Hampshire | Courtney Krumrine, Drexel |
| Joanna Dusza, Delaware | Lena Malinowski, Hofstra |
| Gretchen Lavender, Hofstra | Cari Sanders, New Hampshire |
| Maureen McCarthy, New Hampshire | Jessica Knott, Northeastern |
| April Yantis, Drexel | Jessica Beck, Towson |
|
| 1996 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Joanna Dusza, Delaware | Jessica Beck, Towson |
| Karen Kunselman, Delaware | Jen Falk, Drexel |
| Lena Malinowksi, Hofstra | Heather Hutson, Towson |
| Beth Parr, Hofstra | Courtney Krumrine, Drexel |
| Laura Taneyhill, Towson | Andrea Natale, Hofstra |
| April Yantis, Drexel | Carolyn Powell, Northeastern |
|
| 1995 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Karen Kunselman, Delaware | Nikki Brassell, Delaware |
| Emily Rome, Delaware | Paoloa Escobar, Drexel |
| April Yantis, Drexel | Albertine de Haan, Hofstra |
| Bianca Feldkoetter, Hartford | Melissa Nelson |
| Heleen Hilhorst, Hofstra | Danyel Noward, Northeastern |
| Beth Parr, Hofstra | Stacy Humphries, Towson |
|
| 1994 All-Conference |
| First Team |
|
| Nikki Brassel, Delaware |
|
| Heleen Hilhorst, Hofstra |
| Kathy Shaw, Delaware |
| Naomi Shimada, Hofstra |
| Kim Spottswood, Drexel |
| Stephanie Szorc, Hartford |
|
| 1993 All-Conference |
| First Team |
| Emily Rome, Delaware |
| Agnes Dusza, Drexel |
| Kim Spottswood, Drexel |
| Audrey Dahlstrom, Hartford |
| Bianca Feldkoetter, Hartford |
| Kimerlee Watterson, Northeastern |
|
| 1992 All-Conference |
| First Team |
| Kim Diehlmann, Hartford |
| Kimerlee Watterson, Northeastern |
| Cathy Bissinger, Vermont |
| Phoebe Folke, Delaware |
| Melanie Kopka, Drexel |
| Amy Guidice, Drexel |
|
| 1991 All-Conference |
| First Team |
| Cathy Bissenger, Vermont |
| Kim Diehlmann, Hartford |
| Phoebe Folke, Delaware |
| Chris Frein-Hale, Northeastern |
| Melanie Kopka, Drexel |
| Deb Naylor, Drexel |