| Rookie of the Year |
| 2007 |
Myckie Lugbauer, C/DH, Maine |
| 2006 |
Kevin MacAvoy, 3B, Maine |
| 2005 |
Scott Diamond, SP, Binghamton |
| 2004 |
Miguel Magrass, 3B, Vermont |
| 2003 |
Greg Norton, RHP, Maine |
| 2002 |
Jon Lewis, RHP, Stony Brook |
| 2001 |
Mike Collar, RHP, Maine |
| 2000 |
Joe Drapeau, 3B, Maine |
| 1999 |
Mike Ross, OF, Maine |
| 1998 |
Bruce Boehm, LHP/1B, Drexel |
| 1997 |
Kevin Mench, OF, Delaware |
| 1996 |
Lou Marchetti, C, Drexel |