| Pitcher of the Year |
| 2007 |
Gary Novakowski, RHP, Stony Brook |
| 2006 |
Zach Groh, RHP, Binghamton |
| 2005 |
Adam Ottavino, RHP, Northeastern |
| 2004 |
Jordan Thomson, RHP, Northeastern |
| 2003 |
Jamie Merchant, RHP, Vermont |
| 2002 |
Mike MacDonald, RHP, Maine |
| 2001 |
Rusty Tucker, LHP, Maine |
| 2000 |
Rich McGuire, RHP, Delaware |
| 1999 |
Greg Montalbano, LHP, Northeastern |
| 1998 |
Matt Phillips, RHP, Delaware |
| 1997 |
Garrett Quinn, RHP, Maine |
| 1996 |
Justin Romano, Hofstra |
| 1995 |
Jamie Wilson, Delaware |
| 1994 |
Jeremy Benson, Delaware |
| 1993 |
Mark Ballard, RHP, Maine |
| 1992 |
Jason Pierson, Delaware |
| 1991 |
Larry Thomas, LHP, Maine |
| 1990 |
David Adam, Central Connecticut |