| 2007-08 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | All Rookie | All Defensive
|
| Brian Lillis, Albany | Mike Gordon, Binghamton | Lazar Trifunovic, Binghamton
| Tim Ambrose, Albany
| Brian Lillis, Albany |
Joe Zeglinski, Hartford
| Corey Lowe, Boston University | John Holland, Boston University | John Holland, Boston University
| Mike Gordon, Binghamton |
Jay Greene, UMBC
| Ray Barbosa, UMBC
| Mark Socoby, Maine
| Morgan Sabia, Hartford
| John Holland, Boston U.
|
Darryl Proctor, UMBC
| Brian Hodges, UMBC | Cavell Johnson, UMBC
| Alvin Abreu, New Hampshire
| Cavell Johnson, UMBC
|
| Marqus Blakely, Vermont | Mike Trimboli, Vermont
| Tyrece Gibbs, New Hampshire
| Tyrone Conley, New Hampshire
| Marqus Blakely,
Vermont |
| 2006-07 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | All Rookie | All Defensive |
| Jason Siggers, Albany | Mike Gordon, Binghamton | Brent Wilson, Albany | Lazar Trifunovic, Binghamton | Brian Lillis, Albany |
| Jamar Wilson, Albany | Tyler Morris, Boston U. | Omari Peterkin, Boston U. | Corey Lowe, Boston U. | Mike Gordon, Binghamton |
| Bo Taylor, Hartford | Kevin Reed, Maine | Jermaine Anderson, New Hampshire | Tyler Morris, Boston U. | Chris Pugh, UMBC |
| Mike Trimboli, Vermont | Brian Hodges, UMBC | Ricky Lucas, Stony Brook | Joe Zeglinski, Hartford | Jermaine Anderson, New Hampshire |
| Chris Holm, Vermont | Blagoj Janev, New Hampshire | Martin Klimes, Vermont | Joe Trapani, Vermont | Martin Klimes, Vermont |
| 2005-06 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Jamar Wilson, Albany | Sebastian Hermenier, Binghamton | Brent Wilson, Albany |
| Andre Heard, Binghamton | Aaron Cook, Hartford | Kirsten Zoellner, Albany |
| Kevin Gardner, Boston U. | Ernest Turner, Maine | Mike Gordon, Binghamton |
| Kenny Adeleke, Hartford | John Zito, UMBC | Mitchell Beauford, Stony Brook |
| Blagoj Janev, New Hampshire | Mike Trimboli, Vermont | Martin Klimes, Vermont |
| 2004-05 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Rashad Bell, Boston U. | Lucious Jordan, Albany | Etienne Brower,Boston U. |
| Chaz Carr, Boston U. | Jamar Wilson, Albany | Aaron Cook, Hartford |
| Jose Juan Barea, Northeastern | Andre Heard, Binghamton | Joe Campbell, Maine |
| Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | Kevin Reed, Maine | Marcus Barnes, Northeastern |
| T.J. Sorrentine, Vermont | Ben Sturgill, New Hampshire | Shawn James, Northeastern |
| 2003-04 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Chaz Carr, Boston U. | Nick Billings, Binghamton | Brandon Carter, Binghamton |
| Jason Grochowalski, Boston U. | Eric Dobson, Maine | Ryan Butt, Boston U. |
| Jose Juan Barea, Northeastern | Mark Flavin, Maine | Shaun Wynn, Boston U. |
| Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | Kevin Reed, Maine | Ryan Stys, Hartford |
| T.J. Sorrentine, Vermont | D.J. Munir, Stony Brook | Javorie Wilson, Northeastern |
| 2002-03 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Anthony Green, Binghamton | Jamar Wilson, Albany | Ryan Butt, Boston U. |
| Rashad Bell, Boston U. | Nick Billings, Binghamton | Jose Juan Barea, Northeastern |
| Jerell Parker, Hartford | Billy Collins, Boston U. | Sylbrin Robinson, Northeastern |
| Rickey White, Maine | Justin Rowe, Maine | Javorie Wilson, Northeastern |
| Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | D.J. Munir, Stony Brook | Grant Anderson, Vermont |
| 2001-02 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Chris Brown, New Hampshire | Chaz Carr, Boston U. | Jean Bain, Northeastern |
| Billy Collins, Boston U. | Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont | Will Brand, Albany |
| Trevor Gaines, Vermont | Austin Ganly, New Hampshire | Pierre Johnson, Hartford |
| Justin Rowe, Maine | Errick Greene, Maine | Jeffrey St. Fort, Binghamton |
| T.J. Sorrentine, Vermont | D.J. Munir, Stony Brook | Ryan Stys, Hartford |
| 2000-01 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Carvell Ammons, Maine | Ajmal Basit, Delaware | Brian Barber, Towson |
| Mike Kouser, Drexel | Julian Dunkley, Maine | Marcus Blossom, Northeastern |
| Tony Orciari, Vermont | Jason Hernandez, Hofstra | Ricky Cranford, Northeastern |
| Norman Richardson, Hofstra | Joe Linderman, Drexel | Roberto Gittens, Hofstra |
| Stephen Starks, Drexel | Sam Sutton, Towson | Billy Wells, Delaware |
| 1999-00 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Andy Bedard, Maine | Brian Barber, Towson | Marcus Blossom, Northeastern |
| Craig Claxton, Hofstra | Huggy Dye, Maine | Tobe Carberry, Vermont |
| Nate Fox, Maine | Roberto Gittens, Hofstra | Julian Dunkley, Maine |
| Tony Orciari, Vermont | Mike Kouser, Drexel | John Gordon, Delaware |
| Mike Pegues, Delaware | Norman Richardson, Hofstra | Kestutis Marciulionis, Delaware |
| 1998-99 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Andy Bedard, Maine | Justin Bailey, Hartford | Marcus Blossom, Northeastern |
| Craig Claxton, Hofstra | Mike DeRocckis, Drexel | LeVar Folk, Boston U. |
| John Gordon, Delaware | Nate Fox, Maine | Roberto Gittens, Hofstra |
| Joe Linderman, Drexel | Mike Kouser, Drexel | Allen Ledbetter, Maine |
| Mike Pegues, Delaware | Norman Richardson, Hofstra | Tony Orciari, Vermont |
| 1997-98 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Justin Bailey, Hartford | Walter Brown, Boston U. | Matt Acres, New Hampshire |
| Craig Claxton, Hofstra | Mike DeRocckis, Drexel | Billy Beal, Boston U. |
| Joe Linderman, Drexel | Allen Ledbetter, Maine | Joey Beard, Boston U. |
| Erik Nelson, Vermont | Ty Mack, Northeastern | Ralph Biggs, Towson |
| Mike Pegeus, Delaware | Tony Orciari, Vermont | Keith Davis, Delaware |
| 1996-97 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team |
| Tunji Awojobi, Boston U. | Joey Beard, Boston U. | Craig Claxton, Hofstra |
| John Gordon, Maine | Anthony Bethune, Hartford | Chuck Guittar, Drexel |
| Ryan Howse, Hartford | Keith Davis, Delaware | Joe Linderman, Drexel |
| Jeff Myers, Drexel | Mike DeRocckis, Drexel | Erik Nelson, Vermont |
| Greg Smith, Delaware | Terry Hunt, Maine | Jim Schawartz, Boston U. |
| 1995-96 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Malik Rose, Drexel | Matt Alosa, New Hampshire |
| Tunji Awojobi, Boston U. | Greg Logan, Maine |
| Eddie Benton, Vermont | Patrick Evans, Delaware |
| Greg Smith, Delaware | Ralph Blalock, Towson |
| Jeff Myers, Drexel | Casey Arena, Maine |
| 1994-95 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Scott Drapeau, New Hampshire | Mike Bond, Hartford |
| Tunji Awojobi, Boston U. | Ken Barnes, Maine |
| Malik Rose, Drexel | Dan Callahan, Northeastern |
| Brian Holden, Drexel | Matt Alosa, New Hampshire |
| Eddie Benton, Vermont | Casey Arena, Maine |
| 1993-94 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Tunji Awojobi, Boston U. | Brian Pearl, Delaware |
| Brian Holden, Drexel | Jack Ayer, Hartford |
| Malik Rose, Drexel | Mike Bond, Hartford |
| Scott Drapeau, New Hampshire | Francois Bouchard, Maine |
| Eddie Benton, Vermont | Eric Montanari, New Hampshire |
| 1992-93 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Spencer Dunkley, Delaware | David Stiff, Boston U. |
| Brian Holden, Drexel | Anthony Wright, Delaware |
| Malik Rose, Drexel | Brian Pearl, Delaware |
| Vin Baker, Hartford | Anthony Brown, Northeastern |
| Eddie Benton, Vermont | Dan Callahan, Northeastern |
| 1991-92 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Michael Thompson, Drexel | Jason Scott, Boston U. |
| Alex Coles, Delaware | Jonathan Raab, Drexel |
| Mark Murray, Delaware | Marty Higgins, Maine |
| Vin Baker, Hartford | Derrick Hodge, Maine |
| Kevin Roberson, Vermont | James Ben, New Hampshire |
| 1990-91 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Jason Scott, Boston U. | Reggie Stewart, Boston U. |
| Vin Baker, Hartford | Derrick Hodge, Maine |
| Ron Moye, Hartford | Maurice Brighthaupt, Northeastern |
| Matt Johnson, Vermont | Steve Carney, Northeastern |
| Kevin Roberson, Vermont | Marcellus Anderson, Northeastern |
| 1989-90 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Steven Key, Boston U. | Larry Griffiths, Hartford |
| Lamont Middleton, Hartford | Al Jones, Hartford |
| Roy Moye, Hartford | Barry Abercrombie, Northeastern |
| Dean Smith, Maine | George Yuille, Northeastern |
| Steve Carney, Northeastern | Kevin Roberson, Vermont |
| 1988-89 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Jeff Timberlake, Boston U. | Tony DeCosta, Boston U. |
| Lamont Middleton, Hartford | Ron Moses, Boston U. |
| Patrick Jones, Niagara | Derrick Lewis, Northeastern |
| Marc Brown, Siena | Steve McCoy, Siena |
| Jeffrey Robinson, Siena | Joe Calavita, Vermont |
| 1987-88 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Drederic Irving, Boston U. | Marvin Bailey, Canisius |
| Larry Jones, Boston U. | Brian Smith, Canisius |
| Anthony Moye, Hartford | Marvin Powell, Hartford |
| Kevin McDuffie, Northeastern | John Williams, Northeastern |
| Steve McCoy, Siena | Marc Brown, Siena
|
| Rick WIlliams, Siena |
| 1986-87 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Paul Hendricks, Boston U. | Drederick Irving, Boston U. |
| Jim Boylen, Maine | Chris Heinold, Canisius |
| Joe Arlauckas, Niagara | Brian Smith, Canisius |
| Andre LaFleur, Northeastern | Matt Brady, Siena |
| Reggie Lewis, Northeastern | Joe Calavita, Vermont |
| 1985-86 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Drederick Irving, Boston U. | Tom Ivey, Boston U. |
| Tim Harvey, Canisius | Chris Heinold, Canisius |
| Joe Arlauckas, Niagara | Ulysses Garcia, Hartford |
| Andre LaFleur, Northeastern | Mark Mitchell, Hartford |
| Reggie Lewis, Northeastern | Dirk Koopman, New Hampshire |
| John Williams, Northeastern |
| 1984-85 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Ray Hall, Canisius | Paul Hendericks, Boston U. |
| Shawn Teague, Boston U. | Joe Arlauckas, Niagara |
| Mike Smrek, Canisius | Andre LaFleur, Northeastern |
| Reggie Lewis, Northeastern | Matt Brady, Siena |
| Doug Poetzsch, Siena | Quinton Dale, Northeastern |
| 1983-84 All-Conference |
| First Team | Second Team |
| Gary Plummer, Boston U. | Shawn Teague, Boston U. |
| Ray Hall, Canisius | Jeff Cross, Maine |
| Robert Turner, Canisius | Don Nolan, New Hampshire |
| Al McClain, New Hampshire | Reggie Lewis, Northeastern |
| Mark Halsel, Northeastern | Jeff Sturgeon, Maine |
| 1982-83 All-Conference |
| Robin Dixon, New Hampshire |
| Tony Simms, Boston U. |
| Chris Logan, Holy Cross |
| Jeff Cross, Maine |
| Mark Halsel, Northeastern |
| 1981-82 All-Conference |
| Kevin Greaney, Holy Cross |
| James Speaks, Niagara |
| Mark Halsel, Northeastern |
| Perry Moss, Northeastern |
| Mike Evelti, Vermont |
| 1980-81 All-Conference |
| Steve Wright, Boston U. |
| Mike Ferrara, Colgate |
| Tom Seaman, Holy Cross |
| Pete Harris, Northeastern |
| Chip Rucker, Northeastern |
| Mike Evelti, Vermont |
| 1979-80 All-Conference |
| Mike Ferrara, Colgate |
| Ron Perry, Holy Cross |
| Rufus Harris, Maine |
| Pete Harris, Northeastern |
| James Wright, Rhode Island |
| Steve Wright, Rhode Island |