| Scholar Athlete |
| 2007 | Jackie Kane, Binghamton
|
| 2006 | Megan Hoag, Binghamton
|
| 2005 | Ashlee Reed, Albany
|
| 2004 | Susan Spierre, Albany
|
| 2003 | Rachel Goldsmith, Stony Brook |
| 2002 | Alissa Gibbs, Albany |
| 2001 | Alissa Gibbs, Albany |
| 2000 | Stefanie Rewitz, Hofstra |
| 1999 | Lisa Nolan, Northeastern |
| 1998 | Lisa Nolan, Northeastern |
| 1997 | Lindsey Birkel, Hofstra |
| 1996 | Jen Falk, Drexel |
| 1995 | Heleen Hilhorst, Hofstra |
| 1994 | Kathy Shaw, Drexel |
| 1993 | Bianca Feldkoetter, Hartford |
| 1992 | Melanie Kopka, Drexel |
| 1991 | Melanie Kopka, Drexel |